A big toe that stiffens and aches with each step is a common reason people start searching, and the first job is to name the likely joint problem.
Hallux rigidus is the usual name
HSS describes hallux rigidus as stiffness and pain in the big toe caused by arthritis of the metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint. If your toe is stiff and sore, that is the condition to read about first.
AAOS OrthoInfo lists pain in the big toe joint during walking or other activities among the symptoms of hallux rigidus. Pain that shows up when you walk is therefore a useful detail to track.
What the symptoms tell you
Symptoms of hallux rigidus can vary, and AAOS OrthoInfo notes that they may include one or more of the listed signs. That means two people can describe the same joint differently. Track what you feel and when you feel it, starting with walking, since that is the activity the guidance names.
The OrthoInfo page on the stiff big toe is the plainest place to compare your symptoms against that list. For a deeper look at the clinical side, the PubMed Central article Hallux Rigidus: Current Concepts Review and Treatment Algorithm covers the condition and its treatment options, including interposition arthroplasty.
What to plan next
Because the joint is arthritic, the useful question is how the toe will behave over the coming years, not only how it feels this week. Bring a short log of when the pain appears to your appointment so the follow-up plan is built on a pattern, not a single day.
Readers in Darien, Illinois, and the nearby Downers Grove Township and Chicago metro area who also have arthritis elsewhere in the foot and ankle may want wider context. The Cleveland Clinic explanation of ankle replacement surgery and recovery shows what upkeep can look like for another arthritic joint. If you are weighing a different cause for the pain, the Arthritis Foundation's page on treatments for gout is a place to compare.
A careful note on upkeep
A stiff joint is a long-term account, not a one-time repair. Count the follow-up visits and the daily adjustments as part of the cost of any plan you choose.