Shoes and braces are the daily hardware of living with an arthritic ankle, which makes the choice of both a recurring cost rather than a one-time purchase. Two sources give a starting point.
Shoes with more support and stiffer soles
The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (OrthoInfo), in its guidance on rheumatoid arthritis of the foot and ankle, says shoes that provide more support or have soles that are more rigid (not as flexible) will help protect the foot and ankle from bending forces while standing or walking.
Braces, tape and casts
Cleveland Clinic, writing about high ankle sprains, says your provider might recommend a brace, tape, or even some type of cast to help you avoid bending your ankle up toward your body. That passage concerns a sprain rather than arthritis, but it shows the range of supports a provider can reach for.
For more reading on braces and casts, see this meta-analysis of removable braces versus cast immobilization for ankle fractures and this review on managing ankle fractures in older adults.
Fitting the choice to your ankle
Take the shoes you wear most to the visit and ask the provider to look at the soles and the support. Ask whether a brace is right for your ankle and what the plan is if it is not. A Darien, Illinois, reader trying a brace for the first time can also ask how its fit will be reviewed.
Upkeep
Supportive footwear only helps while it is worn. Bring the shoes you rely on to each review of the ankle, so the provider can check them against the support described above.